The Carbon Credit Conundrum
Carbon credits were designed as a market mechanism to incentivize projects that sequester carbon and reduce carbon emissions. The idea is to pay people who are doing climate friendly projects, and sell credits to carbon emitters. But do they work? Is there independent verification that carbon is really being sequestered? What does it mean when people are being paid for projects they would have been doing anyway? And who’s really profiting? Ecosystem scientist Jane Zelikova, director of the Soil Carbon Solutions Center at Colorado State University and Quivira Coalition board member, guides us through these questions and more.
Learn more about Jane’s work in the upcoming webinar series starting February 20.
Show Notes
2’30 what are carbon credits?
4’49 example of carbon offsets, e.g. the airline industry
5’54 examples of carbon offsets on the ground
7’52 voluntary vs. involuntary/regulatory carbon markets
10’50 who’s getting rich, are the people doing the actual work getting their share
11’55 measurement and verification
13’18 producers don’t always get a significant share, and it’s all dependent on sequestration rates
15’44 does the money from carbon credits help farmer do things that they wouldn’t otherwise do, or paying them to do things that they’re already doing
19’15 how to certify and verify that the projects are real
21’58 there’s no agency that oversees carbon credit markets
23’29 no incentives for truth-telling, no checks and balances; the system is based on trust and wanting to do good
25’26 what is the “conundrum”?
27’18 Jane’s own opinion on carbon credits
29’22 are there enough offsets on the planet to bring the system back into balance?
30’06 even if we stopped all carbon emissions we’d still have to absorb a great deal of legacy carbon
31’17 the role that regenerative agriculture can play
32’18 what is the role of the Soil Carbon Solutions Center in all this
Sky photo by Matthias Heyde on Unsplash
More Episodes
Episode 186 – Fair Trade: Good for farmers, the land, consumers, and business
Fair Trade: Good for farmers, the land, consumers, and business Paul Rice started out as an anti-capitalist labor organizer, working with coffee farmers in Nicaragua in the 1980's. Over time he saw that what growers needed most was a fair price for their product — and...
Episode 185 – Federal Fiasco for Farmers
Federal Fiasco for Farmers Since the new administration took office, programs benefitting farmers have been slashed, frozen, paused, and canceled –– and the effect is leaving them in a tough position. Carolina Mueller, Associate Coalition Director of the National...
Episode 184 – Let it Flow: Restoring Balance to Parched and Flooded Landscapes
Let it Flow: Restoring Balance to Parched and Flooded Landscapes Minni Jain and Philip Franses are co-founders of The Flow Partnership, and they are co-authors of the new book, The Language of Water: Ancient Techniques and Community Stories for a Water Secure Future....